Assessment of work for Broad General Education phase


We assess reading in the Broad General Education in a number of ways:

  • Close Reading (questions relating to increasingly complex fiction and non-fiction texts);
  • Personal Reading (tracked by quizzes taken on the Accelerated Reader Programme)
  • Critical Reading (extended critical reviews of poems, plays, novels, short stories and media texts studied as a class).


These assessment approaches prepare pupils for the demands Reading in the senior phase:

  • Close Reading is assessed in Paper 1 (Reading for Understanding, Analysis and Evaluation)
  • Critical Reading (writing critically about literary texts) is assessed in Paper 2
  • Pupils who develop a regular Personal Reading habit reap the reward in their own writing (the Writing folio accounts for 30% of the award at Nat 5, Higher and Advanced Higher).


When we assess pupils’ writing skills in the Broad General Education, we take account of their work across different genre:

  • broadly creative pieces (personal, reflective, short stories, poems, scripts and imagined responses to literature like letters and diary entries)
  • broadly discursive (reports, newspaper articles, discursive essays and persuasive writing).

S1-S3 we look for progression in: length; complexity of ideas, structure, vocabulary and expression; and pupils’ ability to write with increasing independence. These types of writing (broadly creative and broadly discursive) are a crucial part of assessment in the Senior Phase (30% at National 5, Higher and Advanced Higher).


Talking & Listening

Pupils’ talking & listening skills are developed and assessed through traditional activities such as:

  • group discussion (with assigned roles of chairperson, scribe, reporter and timekeeper)
  • solo talks (with time to research, prompt cards, slides and questions from the audience)
  • analysis of spoken texts (akin to the Listening Assessments in National 4, 5 and Higher)
  • whole class discussion and questioning (a crucial part of exploring literature and non-fiction and in preparing for writing)
  • reading aloud (a part in a play for example).
  • debating (with formal roles of proposition and opposition, challenges in the form of ‘points of information’ and judges deciding the outcome of the debate)
  • hot seating and role play
  • dragon’s den style competitions; circle games; poetry slams.


We provide both written and oral feedback on pupil work. Formal assessments (e.g. final copies of essays or notecards from a solo talk) will be attached to a cover sheet with feedback and kept in individual ‘good work folders’. Self and peer assessment approaches are also central to our work in this aspect of learning.


Report a Glow concern
Cookie policy  Privacy policy

Glow Blogs uses cookies to enhance your experience on our service. By using this service or closing this message you consent to our use of those cookies. Please read our Cookie Policy.