Month: January 2021

IB Reflective Activity 4

The Curriculum for Excellence (CfE) and the Primary Years Practice (PYP) have many similarities. Engagement is a key area for both curricula with student centred learning being a method both employ as a way to achieve this participation.

PYP is built around 10 core attributes for the pupils to focus on as they grow and develop into inquiring, knowledgeable and caring people who help to create a better and more peaceful world through intercultural understanding and respect. In teaching the learning is delivered in a transdisciplinary manner to add more relevance to the learning. Cross-curricular teaching can also be found in CfE where learning is given more breadth in teaching students more than one subject at a time. By teaching this way students are able to see the applications for their learning out with the school environment, leading to more engagement and hopefully more learning taking place.

As PYP is designed to be delivered across the globe, one major element to it is encouraging pupils to make connections with their learning and begin to understand the world they live and participate in. In investigating and understanding their own culture pupils can contrast, compare and have compassion for other cultures they come across in their life. CfE does not look outward in the scale PYP does. Despite this within CfE Religious and Moral Education offers a time and place to explore and develop pupils’ knowledge of the world around them and their place in it. Comparing the two curricula, PYP has more of an emphasis on this aspect of education however it is not lacking from CfE, just not as central.

In CfE Technologies is highlighted as a subject in itself that can be taught as an interdisciplinary lesson, or by itself however in PYP there is no subject for technologies. In PYP it is expected each lesson should include technologies in some way and pupils should gradually learn the technology skills they need throughout their time in PYP.

Overall both curricula equip pupils with the skills they need for life after and above school. Both curricula encourage an environment centred around life-long learning and constant improvement.

PYP Curricular Areas	CfE Curricular Areas
Language	Language and Literacy
Mathematics	Mathematics and Numeracy
Science	Sciences
Social Studies	Social Studies
Arts	Expressive Arts
Personal, Social and Physical Education	Health and Wellbeing
	Technologies
	Religious and Moral Education

IB Reflective Activity 3

Looking at the ‘progressive’ trends highlighted in the IB documentation I can see they are more aligned with current values and methods I have seen implemented in practice in CfE  classrooms.

Transdisciplinary learning can be seen in CfE in the form of ‘interdisciplinary learning’. This can be through a central topic used to investigate subjects such as maths and science at the same time, or drama and religious education. Using interdisciplinary learning allows children to make connections between different areas of their learning and enables them to see the relevancy of the learning happening in the classroom. Learners can use the pairing of varying skills to apply to problems to enhance their critical thinking and problem solving skills .

Child-centred learning takes place in the classroom when the focus of the lesson changes from being didactic to pupil-lead. By focussing on listening and talking in the classroom (one element of CfE) the teacher can elicit new ideas and opinions from the class while simultaneously working on their communication skills. When the class are engaged and have the ability to take part in sharing they become active participants in the lesson and in turn the lesson becomes more specialised to the specific class being taught. Increasing the relevancy and therefore also raising pupil engagement.

Education of the whole child can be clearly seen in the SHANARRI wheel. By ‘getting it right for every child’ using the SHANARRI wheel teachers and other educational practitioners can provide a tailored education to each child in their care. SHANARRI provides a framework on what and how to educate topics going further than specific subjects such as mathematics or science. By looking closer at aspects of the pupil’s life such as; their knowledge on how to keep themselves safe; how to know when they are being respected; or how to live a healthy, active life. These life skills go past academic subjects but are just as relevant to equipping pupils with the necessary tools to succeed.

 

Extension Activity

John Dewey – focuses on the importance of tapping into students natural curiosity. This can be seen in CfE when looking at the attribute ‘successful learners’. This section of CfE looks at developing pupils’ enthusiasm and motivation for learning while nurturing a determination to reach high standards of achievement. In IB this same notion can be seen in the ‘learner profile’s 10 core attributes’ where both thinkers and inquirers are key areas of development for pupils throughout their IB education.

A.S Neill – focused on the idea of students developing in an environment free from constraints, having personal freedom for children in their education. Looking at CfE we can see this line of thinking in ‘effective contributors’ where pupils are guided towards an enterprising attitude, resilience and self-reliance. One of the Progressive Education Trends that are present in the IB curriculum is ‘multiple perspectives’. When applied to learning this gives the pupils autonomy in their own education to create and develop their own opinion and standpoints.

Jean Piaget – specialises in the idea that children develop academic intelligence through a cognitive cycle. Looking to CfE this theory is seen in the levels of the curriculum, and the skills that progress through these levels. They are tailored to the means and capacity of the age they are aimed at but can be accessed by anyone who requires that level of work. In IB curriculum the 6 transdisciplinary ideas can be worked to suit any level of cognitive ability and also have the added benefit of adding relevance to the pupil’s learning.

Jerome Bruner – looked at how self-discovery of information improves the problem solving skills of pupils. In CfE problem solving is focused on in one of the four capacities – ‘effective contributors’. In this the ability to solve problems, apply critical thinking and new contexts and to take the imitative and lead are all key elements. In being transferable skills these aspects can be used in other curriculum areas. A main focus of the IB curriculum is to develop effective teaching and learning approaches. In doing so the pupils have the tools to learn knowledge and facts without a guide such as a teacher and can embark on a learning journey in applying their skills to problem solving where ever they desire.

IB Reflective Activity 2

When comparing the IB curriculum to the Curriculum for Excellence we can see both similarities such as relevancy, pupils’ wellbeing, and independence and differences such as a more specific curriculum or a more global world view. A key underlying focus central to both curriculums is the wellbeing of the child – physically, emotionally and mentally.

Looking closer at the similarities I can see relevancy is a central goal in both curriculums. In Curriculum for Excellence the importance of the relevancy of the childrens’ learning can be seen when looking closely at ‘Responsible Citizens’. One requirement of this is to have knowledge of histories and culture in Scotland and the similarities and differences to the histories and cultures of the rest of the world. Leading on from this the Curriculum for Excellence also looks at ensuring pupils can participate responsibly in political, economic, social and cultural life. For this they need the knowledge of Scotland’s way of life, and other ways to contrast and find their own viewpoints and opinions.

In the IB curriculum we can see the same focus on relevancy and place in the world in the focus ‘works within global contexts’. This is important as the IB curriculum is designed to be delivered across many countries and cultures. This part of the curriculum looks at increasing pupil understanding of cultures and explores globally significant ideas and issues, similar to the focuses of ‘responsible citizens’ in the Curriculum for Excellence.

A second similarity is the methods both curricula want the children to be able to communicate and work in. in IB the focus is children ‘developing effective teaching and learning approaches’ and within this developing characteristics such as communication, reflection and inquiry. In Curriculum for Excellence skills such as working in partnership, and taking initiative fall into the ‘effective contributors’. Looking closely at this section of CfE we can see a spotlight on transferable skills such as resilience, taking leadership roles and problem solving.

Where there are similarities between International Baccalaureate and Curriculum for Excellence there are also differences as they are different curricula at their cores and have different main goals. While CfE is very broad in that there are only 4 capacities (within these each main focus is broken down), IB has more specific requirements of the pupils in the ‘Learner Profile’ containing 10 core attributes each pupil must stive towards.  On top of this the CfE, while having some requirement for looking out with Scotland, does not do so in the amount of detail as IB looks at global ideas and issues.

The 10 learner profile attributes found in IB are prevalent in other curriculums, such as CfE, and also out with education as a whole. In my personal experience as a pupil in both Scottish education system and English education system I have experienced some of the attributes myself. These being; ‘communicators’, ‘caring’ and ‘thinkers’. In CfE classrooms in my experience being ‘effective contributors’ is similar to both ‘communicators’ and ‘caring’. From my experience on the other side of the curtain, being a teacher in the classroom, I find myself striving to assist in the growth of other attributes for example ‘open-minded’, ‘risk takers’, and ‘principled’. I think this shows the IB curriculum to be both relevant to life beyond school and life in all countries as I experienced the same values with 2 other curricula.