Comparison of Voice-Only Accessibility Features for Users with Mobility Issues

FeatureiPadOSWindowsChromeOS
Full Voice NavigationVoice Control: Allows users to control the entire device using voice commands, including gestures, swiping, and text input.Voice Access: Enables full system control via voice commands, including opening apps, navigation, and text entry.Voice Dictation: Supports text input but limited control of navigation. ChromeVox supports some voice-based navigation.
Text InputSiri Dictation: Built-in for hands-free typing in text fields and apps.Windows Dictation: Allows text input with voice, integrated into system-wide apps.Voice Dictation: Provides basic speech-to-text in supported fields.
App LaunchingSupported through Voice Control or Siri: Users can open apps, send messages, and make calls using voice commands.Supported through Voice Access: Apps can be launched, switched, and closed. Copilot can also launch apps.Google Assistant/Gemini can launch apps but lacks full device navigation capabilities.
Custom Voice CommandsVoice Control allows custom voice commands for tasks, actions, and automation.Voice Access supports creating custom commands for frequently used tasks.Limited to ChromeOS extensions or third-party tools for custom commands.
Navigation ShortcutsUsers can navigate by saying commands like “Swipe right,” “Tap,” “Scroll down,” etc.Voice Access enables precise navigation with commands like “Click item,” “Scroll up/down,” and grid-based navigation.ChromeVox supports some grid-based navigation but not as extensive as Windows or iPadOS.
Dictation EditingUsers can dictate, edit, and replace text hands-free with Siri or Voice Control.Voice Access allows advanced text correction and editing commands like “Replace [word].”Basic editing supported, but less robust compared to iPadOS and Windows.
Web BrowsingSafari supports voice commands and reading webpages aloud via Voice Control and Siri.Edge and Chrome support voice-based navigation and text-to-speech via Voice Access.Limited voice browsing; Select-to-Speak assists with webpage reading.
Voice AssistantSiri: Integrated for general commands, app launching, reminders, and dictation.Cortana: Supports basic voice tasks like opening apps, sending emails, and reminders.Google Assistant: Supports web searches, app launching, and reminders.
Hands-Free AutomationShortcuts App: Automates repetitive tasks through voice activation.Windows Power Automate can script automations that integrate with Voice Access.Google Assistant can automate basic tasks but lacks advanced voice scripting.
Accessibility FocusUsers can say “Show Numbers” to select items on the screen using overlays.Voice Access grid-based overlays allow precise control of screen elements.Limited overlay functionality; basic tab and element navigation via ChromeVox.

Observations:

  • iPadOS:
    • Voice Control stands out as the most comprehensive feature for voice-only workflows. It allows complete device navigation, text editing, app launching, and gesture simulation.
    • Siri enhances functionality with quick app launching, reminders, and automation through the Shortcuts App.
  • Windows:
    • Voice Access provides precise navigation through grid overlays, advanced text editing, and custom voice commands.
    • Copilot supports:
      • System Control: Change system settings like Bluetooth or display modes.
      • File and App Management: Find, open, and ask questions about the contents of files on your device.
      • Voice Interaction: Activate Copilot voice by holding Alt + Spacebar for two seconds for voice-based commands. 
  • ChromeOS:
    • Google Assistant allows basic voice tasks like app launching and reminders.
    • Voice Dictation is limited to text entry, and ChromeVox offers basic screen navigation but lacks the full voice control capabilities seen in iPadOS and Windows.

Summary for Voice-Only Users:

  • Best Option: iPadOS (for intuitive, robust voice-only navigation and editing).
  • Second Best: Windows (for precision and flexibility in voice-based navigation and advanced tasks).
  • Basic Support: ChromeOS (suitable for light usage but lacks advanced voice navigation features).

Report a Glow concern
Cookie policy  Privacy policy