Review by Elaine Swan, Langlees Primary School, Falkirk
Suitable for older 1st level and/or 2nd level
Themes – violence, religious intolerance, partition of India, colonialism, bullying in school, separation from loved ones, friendship, loss,
This was an engaging story right from the start with vivid characters who, despite being the best of friends, kept their own identities and personalities throughout the book. The story also revealed the trauma of Partition without being too overwhelmingly violent (but enough for the reader to get a sense of the utter devastation this caused) so could be read by more able younger readers. It correctly states the deliberate act of violence and self-interest by the British, focusing not just on the horrors of Partition but also the cause.
This historical fiction book got the balance just right between historic facts, information about the different religions (I found the glossary at the back very helpful) and the beauty of India. It was deeply moving at parts, with a rich use of language and I also found it incredibly impactful and made me want to go and read more about the atrocious event. It’s gut wrenching one moment and then hopeful at another. Both educational and memorable and a story I think will enlighten anyone who chooses to read it.
