Tag: Process and Product

Week 12 – Exploring Products and Patterns in Music and Dance

This week was our final week of inputs for Integrated Arts. We learned about and explored the use of the ukulele in the classroom. Before learning more about this instrument I was sceptical about how I (with no previous experience with a ukelele or with anything like it) could possibly use it in a classroom of children. However, learning that many songs can be played using only C, F and G has made me a lot more confident that I could teach children how to use it effectively. To me, this makes the ukelele seem like an instrument which could effectively build the confidence of children who are not initially enthused by music, as it is not much to learn before success is reachable. This feeling of success is fundamental for building resilience as it will inevitably come before or after feelings of failure, especially when children are constantly trying new things. To encourage them to persist and to pursue their interests, even when challenges arise, is a key for their development and for the development of creativity (Lehrer, 2012). Resilience is vital for life within and out with education and some children may struggle more than others to develop it, so I aim to provide as many opportunities for its development as possible. Confidence is a key concept within the arts and it should be developed in children whenever possible (McAullife, 2007). When learning about the ukelele and its place in the classroom today, I considered how the end product – the performance, or the celebration as referred to by Woods (1994), can be used to both expose and improve the confidence, or lack of, in pupils. Woods describes this as the celebration as it should be the time when we feel proud of what we have achieved in the creation process.

Within dance today, we experienced this process of performance and celebration. After working collaboratively to create dances which fitted a Christmas theme last week, today we worked to bring the groups’ dances together one after the other and to add some moves in which all of the groups did at the beginning and end of the routine. We also came up with some ways that each group could move from their dance routine in the middle of the floor, to the side while another group moved in. We filmed the routine and performed it as a celebration of our work. Although some of us felt embarrassed or nervous about filming the dance, it allowed us to watch it back afterwards and to see that the finished product was more impressive than we had first thought! This helped me to feel more confident dancing alongside my colleagues and I will now be more confident dancing in front of and with my future students. We had worked together with our tutor guiding, not dictating, us, and there was a strong sense of ownership between my colleagues. This sense of ownership not only expresses pride, but encourages people to take responsibility for and to strive to further develop any skills and knowledge gained throughout an experience (Craft, 2007). This experience also helped me to consider that sometimes, once we have the product to hand, we forget about the value of the learning and development of skills which have taken place throughout the process. As a teacher I will be more conscious of making sure that I evaluate and ask the pupils to reflect on the process once the product has been created, so as not to devalue it, but to celebrate it. For the children, their reflection may allow them to revisit ideas which they had to put on a shelf along the way for one reason or another. It may also allow them to consider how their perceptions and views about different things have changed and how they can now use movement to express their feelings and ideas in different ways.

Overall, within the contexts of both music and dance today, I considered and experienced the end of the process – the product. I developed a new level of appreciation for its value and for how it can be used not to overshadow the process, but rather as a conclusion of its discoveries.

Furthermore, in music, the four chords concept, shown in the video below, inspired me to create something like this with a class of primary school children one day to show them the transferability of their skill in the use of the ukelele:

Although this particular video would not be suitable for use in a primary school classroom (due to the nature of some of the language used) the concept of it could be developed through teaching of the 4 chords principle and then researching and experimenting with different songs to see which ones fit. A mash-up could then be created of a similar nature to this one and performed with pride and, hopefully, a new found confidence within music! Exploring the concept of the 4 chords lead me to make a natural connection between music and maths: patterns and sequencing. Marshall (2014) discusses the importance of making connections where they come naturally, rather than forcing them, as this allows us to make the inter-disciplinary learning meaningful and to truly integrate subjects. This is evidenced in various aspects of music; the beat is a pattern of short sounds, and the melody often repeats itself in a pattern during the chorus and verses, but this particular sequence adds another opportunity for IDL – Roman Numerals. The principle means that whatever key you are playing in, the four chords you use go in a sequence of 1, 5, 6, 4. Upper case Roman Numerals are used to represent a major chord, and lower case Roman Numerals to represent a minor chord. If, for example, we were playing in the D key, the chords would be D, G, A, B, played in the sequence of D, A, B, G. This form of sequencing and patterns could be experimented with using various different keys to create various different letter patterns and to represent them using sound. This could be an activity used to reach the following outcome: I can continue and devise more involved repeating patterns or designs, using a variety of media. MTH 1-13a. Also, it could be used to aim towards this outcome: I can use my voice, musical instruments and music technology to discover and enjoy playing with sound, rhythm, pitch and dynamics. EXA 1-17a. The Roman Numerals also provide opportunities for exploration of this type of musical sequence to include lessons on number systems; comparing the Roman Numeral System to the Hindu Arabic system, and learning about the history and cultural impacts of the number systems we use today. I have discussed the important part that numbers play in the world and explored a variety of systems that have been used by civilisations throughout history to record numbers. MTH 1-12a. 

Similarly to this, in the dance workshop today, my group and I were considering patterns and sequences of a different sort. Dance routines are often referred to as sequences as, essentially, they are a sequence of moves. We considered the different ways in which we can take a dance to the next level of aesthetic value. My group and I thought about ways in which some of us could do a sequence of moves in a different order to the others in our group.  I was inspired to consider that this concept highlights the use of patterns in dance and could be used to further explore patterns and sequences in the classroom. These patterns could be represented using symbols of the children’s choice – numbers, doodles, shapes, or objects such as shells or coloured crayons. Once the patterns are recorded, the children could assign different moves to the different symbols and represent their patterns using movement. This would highlight the flow of some patterns and the abrupt change of others, and this could in fact be how the children choose to represent their feelings within the dance – is it a soft and easy flowing sequence of moves, or a bold and sharp sequence of moves? Encouraging children to consider their moves first in isolation and then to combine them within a sequence, would hopefully allow them to more easily edit and adapt their sequences to whatever pattern of moves they like best. Editing is very important and should be encouraged within creative processes such as this (Kear and Callaway, 2000).

A move or a single sound in isolation can have a very limited impact. It is the sequence of moves and sounds which create the art forms of dance and music: making sequences a vital aspect, of these two art forms in particular, to consider.

References

Craft, A. (2007) Creativity and possibility thinking in the Early Years. [Online] Available: www.tactyc.org.uk/pdfs/reflection-craft.pdf [Accessed: 1 October 2017].

Kear, M. and Callaway, G. (eds.) (2000) Improving teaching and learning in the arts. London: Falmer Press.

Lehrer, J. (2012) Imagine: How Creativity Works. [Online] Available: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ufnp89NOrel&feature=youtu.be [Accessed: 2 October 2017].

Marshall, J. (2014) Transdisciplinarity And Art Integration: Toward a New Understanding of Art-Based Learning Across The Curriculum. Studies in Art Education. [Online] Vol.55(2), pp.104-127. Available: Taylor & Francis. [Accessed: 17 November 2017].

McAuliffe, D. (2007) Foundation and Primary Settings. In: Cox, S., Watts, R. Grahame, J. Herne, S. and McAuliffe, D. (eds.) Teaching Art and Design 3-11. London: Continuum.

Woods, P. (1994) ‘Chances of a lifetime: exceptional educational events’. In: Bourne, J. (ed.) Thinking Through Primary Practice. London: Routledge.

Week 11 – Process and Product within drama and dance

Today we began by attending a lecture on creative dance. Having previously read Theresa Cone’s work, I found it interesting to relate my now experiences with dance to her writing. Having had previous experience with dance – both as a student at a dance school and as a dance leader working in primary schools – I have enjoyed learning about the theory behind creative dance. Some of the benefits of dance have always been, to me, obvious. It provides people with an interest and a way to keep fit and healthy (both physically and mentally) which is not centred around how well you can throw or catch a ball. However, before learning about it within an artistic sense, I had considered it to be exclusively a sport. This misconception of its limitations is highlighted as being a view of many throughout the world by Gilbert (2005) as she says that many people have viewed it as something which P.E. teachers should deliver. When considering this point, it seems almost ridiculous that a P.E. teacher should be considered as more capable of teaching young children an art form than a class teacher. Therefore, I was encouraged to think about the term ‘creative dance’, which suggests the further development of creativity through expression of feelings and connections to knowledge, rather than simply ‘dance’, which I think we sometimes confuse for exercise to music.

During this morning’s lecture, we considered Smith-Autard’s (2002) Midway Model for Dance in Schools. This model suggests that we should not ignore neither the process nor the product of dance; meaning that the dance must be meaningful and expressive but it should also be aesthetically pleasing. This can be achieved by teaching children the 10 Basic Skills of dance to give them the required skills and knowledge for them to combine these with their imagination and creativity, to come up with dance routines and to solve problems effectively. Reflecting on this, for my own understanding of the connection between the two conventions, I have related it to learning how to read – we must first develop graphic and phonic knowledge before we can develop a strong contextual understanding of the texts we read. Similarly, we must develop the ability to write before we can convey our feelings and creative stories using the written word.

We also took part in a dance input today in which we worked in groups to create a dance with a chosen theme. We chose Christmas and had to plan the dance based on a model created by Cone (2009). This model required us to consider the characters, a storyline and a title for our dance, as well as to consider any props or costumes that we plan to use. We chose the story of the elves making presents on Christmas Eve, before Jack Frost appears and tries to ruin Christmas by freezing all of the hard working elves. But Santa appears right on time and over powers Jack Frost with his jolly ‘Ho Ho Ho!’. We choreographed this dance in our groups today and used the 10 basic steps as well as adding in different conventions such as cannon. Due to the nature of our story, we felt that facial expressions were very important in our routine and that the nature of the moves should reflect the feelings of the characters at any given time. The process of this essentially allowed us to come up with an imaginative story within a theme, which would traditionally be written. However, in this context, we are telling our story through movement. To do this, we had to discuss how the different characters would feel at different points in the story and had to consider incentives and reactions. For this reason, along with so many others, this process of creative dance is so much more enriching and meaningful that copying a dance which a professional has made up. As Heath and Gilbert (2015) argue, copying can only take us so far while creating is limitless. Therefore, the products of dance stories like this have the potential to be both insightful and original. However, it is important to consider that children may require to be prompted to consider how the characters in their story would feel and reminded that they should express these feelings in both their movements and their facial expressions, to effectively and powerfully convey their messages to the audience in an aesthetically pleasing way. Performing our dances next week will allow us to showcase our product and to potentially be inspired by the products of others.

After dance, we moved on to our drama input. We took part in drama lessons which were lead by our colleagues and then my group led our session. We based our lesson on ‘Prince Cinders’ by Babette Cole. In a previous post I discussed how I was feeling before we delivered our lesson and today, after we delivered it, I was feeling pleasantly surprised. The engagement and active participation of our colleagues made it an enjoyable experience. As this was a micro-teaching exercise, I developed my communication skills and practised projecting my voice. I also made sure that I was aware of my position in the room and my colleagues and I practised giving set times to the participants. It was overall a very valuable experience in which we were able to practise general teaching skills along with drama conventions. We focussed mostly on the character of Prince Cinders, who was lonely and had low self-esteem at the beginning of the story, but by the end his horrible brothers were punished and he was rewarded. Looking closely at characters allowed us to use the process of this drama to tell the story in a more meaningful way, and the participants were able to relate to at least one of the characters and to develop justified feelings, whether positive or negative, towards them. As discussed by Jackson and Leahy (2006) drama allows children to be present within and out with a fictional story. This is a very powerful component of drama as it provides children with the opportunity to view things from two different perspectives – their own and that of a character. This allows them to compare the two and to make connections between them, using higher order thinking skills, such as evaluation, to justify both their own feelings and the feelings of the characters in question. This is a particularly sophisticated skill and is related to developing empathy for others. This is just one of the reasons that the process of drama is important.

I have discussed the use of drama to tell stories in previous blog posts, although its ability to teach life lessons in a memorable way is something which I feel, especially in my time spent in education as a pupil, has been overlooked in the past. Drama can allow learners to relate to cultural, social, and environmental world issues that may have previously seemed so distant from their own lives that they struggle to comprehend them. For example, learning about both sustainable education and integrated arts at the same time, has allowed me to increasingly see the connections between the two. Drama inputs can be used to put children into the shoes of almost anyone around the world; from politicians debating about climate change policies, to natural disaster victims and charity aid workers of all ages. I strongly believe that this would help children to make connections with the world in much more powerful ways. Anderson (2004) suggests agreement with this point as he discusses the use of drama in bringing situated learning to the classroom. Taking children to the scene of a natural disaster may be physically impossible. However, bringing the scene of a natural disaster to the classroom through drama is by every means possible!

However we use drama, whether it be to teach lessons about world issues, to teach values, or to develop life skills, the process of the drama is unarguably vital. Although, the product of the drama should not be forgotten. From today’s input, we considered how our colleagues who took part in our drama lesson have now had some practice of drama over the past few months. This meant that the products of the role on the walls, mimes, and response to the teacher in role, were likely more effective than they would have been should we have asked the same group of people to do these tasks without any previous drama input. Therefore, it is important to consider as a teacher that although it is vital to allow the children to guide the process to some extent, teacher input is necessary to structure and encourage student progress. This progress should be evident as over time, the pupils should develop more confidence and should be encouraged to delve out with their comfort zones, ensuring that every pupil is getting a chance to participate and the more dominant pupils are not taking over. The participation of all should lead to a vast range of different perspectives and ideas which should be discussed and evaluated. We should also regularly look back at our products and evaluate them as proof of the effectiveness of the process (QCA, 2004), as well as proof of new skills and ways of thinking.

These inputs today highlighted to me that within all of the arts, the process and the product are equally important.

References 

Anderson, C. (2004) Learning in “As-If” Worlds: Cognition in Drama in Education. Theory Into Practice. [Online] Vol.43(4), pp.281-286. Available: Taylor and Francis. [Accessed: 7 November 2017].

Cone, T. (2009) Following Their Lead: Supporting Children’s Ideas for Creating Dances. Journal of Dance Education. [Online] Vol.9(3), pp.81-89. Available: Taylor & Francis. [Accessed: 19 October 2017].

Gilbert, A. (2005) Dance Education in the 21st Century: A Global Perspective. Journal of Physical Education, Recreation and Dance. [Online] Vol.76(5), pp.26-35. Available: Taylor & Francis. [Accessed: 21 November 2017].

Heath, S. and Gilbert, L. (2015) Creativity and the work of art and science. The Routledge International Handbook of the Arts and Education. [Online] Vol.1(1), pp. 398-409. Available: http://shirleybriceheath.net/pdfs2016/creativity-work-art-science.pdf. [Accessed: 21 October 2017].

Jackson, A. and Leahy, H.R. (2006) ‘Seeing it for real…?’ – Authenticity, theatre and learning in museums. Research in Drama Education: The Journal of Applied Theatre and Performance. [Online] Vol.10(3), pp.303-325. Available: Taylor and Francis. [Accessed: 7 November 2017].

QCA (2004) Creativity: find it, promote it: promoting pupils’ creative thinking and behaviour across the curriculum at key stages 1, 2 and 3: practical materials for schools. [Online] London: Qualifications and Curriculum Authority. Available: www.qca.org.uk/creativity. [Accessed: 19 October 2017].

Smith-Autard, J. (2002) The Art of Dance Education. London: A & C Black Publishers Ltd.