Tag: Art and literacy

Week 4 – Using a Stimulus as Inspiration for Creation

Using a stimulus of any means, such as the house in the painting discussed, gives learners a context which they can first relate to real-life, and then which they can attack with their imagination. Jonah Lehrer (2012) believes that when we imagine things, we take inspiration from real-life and from things in our own minds. The relatable yet ambiguous nature of a house makes it a perfect stimulus for children to consider the real life aspects and also to let their imaginations run wild about what could be happening in the house, as apart from the artist, nobody can tell them that they are wrong. I think that this also encourages Anna Craft’s (2007) ‘possibility thinking’ as we are essentially providing children with a stimulus to ask questions about; we are encouraging them to wonder and then to solve a problem. Craft also discusses her belief of the importance of taking the ideas of learners seriously. I believe that there could not be one idea about what is going on within a big house which could be written off – the element of mystery means that we are not telling learners what is going on but that they are finding out for themselves through critical thinking.

After considering this painting we were given A5 polystyrene sheets and were asked to choose a section of the painting to draw on to our sheets. The only requirement was that the drawing filled the piece of polystyrene. I chose to attempt to replicate the right hand side of the painting. We then used rollers and paint to cover the polystyrene before transferring the paint on to a folded piece of coloured A4 paper to make a print.

          We repeated this process four times before slightly changing our polystyrene drawings – for example by cutting out some of the windows or adding more detail such as brick work. We then used a different colour of paint and transferred this different colour on top of our original copies. This made a range of different prints which had different contrasting colours. Although we were all given the same instructions and the same stimulus, each person’s prints were different. To me, this represented the fact that we all have different perceptions and we all interpret things differently. By using this as a follow up activity to looking into the house in the painting and considering the different people who may live there and the different stories that the house has to tell may encourage children to use certain colours and lines within their prints which to them, represent the mood which the house now conveys due to their imaginary stories of what goes on within it. This could encourage them to think critically about pieces of art instead of passively glancing at them. By allowing them to represent their own thoughts and feelings through careful consideration of the subject matter, we would be improving their higher order thinking skills in many ways.

The process of creating multiple prints in this way would also allow children to amend their work if they were not happy with it, for example they could choose different colours or add more detail to the polystyrene as they made their four prints. This ability to redraft is named by Jonah Lehrer (2012) as essential when making something which has never been made before. If we are teaching a generation of learners to become inventors and to be able to adapt to the demands of a changing environment then I would agree that we must help them to develop the skill of looking at what they have done before and considering how they can improve it. Also, by allowing them to make these changes we will help them to feel proud and happy with their work and to get the most out of the activity.

We then moved on to drama where we used the story of the dragon as a stimulus. As this was our first drama input we started off by discussing our previous experiences of drama and current feelings about it. I did not have much drama experience at school, however I was part of a drama youth group until I was 16 and I found this to be my main escape from the new found pressures of secondary school teenage life. It boosted my self-confidence unbelievably so I have witnessed the power of it in these ways first-hand and hope to be able to affectively use it as such for the learners in my classroom. We considered the fact that drama provides the opportunity for us to be someone else and for us to take on the role of a different character. It was suggested that this is the element of drama which makes it such an excellent escape mechanism as, sadly, for many children their life at home is not as they would wish for it to be.

Also, as Smith (2009) suggests, use of the arts in schools can assist in closing the attainment gap. Children from different backgrounds will have had varying experiences of the arts, and by teaching them in schools we are providing a more even starting point as learners from all backgrounds will have the skills developed by the arts as well as being able to benefit from the escapism of them. The lesson today allowed me to see how drama can be used to convey important messages to children without directly saying, for example, “we shouldn’t judge a book by its cover, things are not always as they seem”. Conveying messages in this way allows the children to understand them rather than to passively listen to them.

As Teresa Grainger (2003, p.45) says “[Drama] is essentially orientated towards both creating and solving social problems.” Today we created a social problem within the context of relationships in a child-friendly way as we took the role of villagers who were worried and upset because a dragon was flying lowly over their village and breathing fire. The villagers took part in a meeting, lead by the mayor of the village (who in this case would be played by the teacher to introduce the drama using Teacher In Role). We discussed and decided on the action we were going to take to stop the dragon from causing more destruction to our village and in groups, we came up with freeze frames which we explained to the group. We all froze doing tribal dances to try to scare away the dragon. However, the dances did not work so we had to have another meeting and decide what to do next. All this time, the teacher should be asking the pupils what they want to do and letting them lead the drama, as this is what will allow them to discover the messages of the drama for themselves, and as Anna Craft (2007) believes, it is when learners discover messages and the meaning of lessons for themselves, that they take that knowledge for their own. After the second meeting we decided to find out where the dragon lived and went to her house to speak to her. This allowed for improvisation as we climbed the mountain to the dragon’s cave and then ‘hot seated’ her by asking her questions about why she was flying so low in the village and breathing fire. It was through this process that the children discovered that the dragon was not trying to terrorise the village – but that she was lonely and was flying so low to get a closer look at the villagers because she loved seeing them so happy and she breathed fire when she got excited. They also found out that she didn’t have enough food to feed her baby dragon. We then considered how we could help the dragon and decided to invite her to the village party, to give her the food we don’t use, and to build her and her baby a home in the village so that she won’t be lonely anymore.

This is where the main lesson lies – it allows learners to see for themselves that things and people are not always as they seem and that sometimes when we think people are trying to cause us harm they are actually lonely and want to get our attention. It also allows children to consider how they can help people like this. Furthermore, if children are engaged in a drama exercise such as this, it can be used by myself as the teacher to relate back to if I find myself having to explain the behaviour of one of their classmates for example. Finally, we considered the use of a thought tunnel. This is where children stand facing one another in two lines and a character, who in this case could have been the dragon walks down the middle of the two lines. As the character walks past them the children have to say exactly what they think of them. This could be done at the beginning of the project/lesson and then again at the end as a way to measure how well the children have grasped the concept and have learned from the main themes, as their feelings towards the character should at least slightly change.

Overall, I think that using a stimulus for creation is a fantastic way to engage children and to put valuable lessons into context. It encourages learners to be thoughtful and critical of how different things work and make them feel, while it also allows them to explore their imagination and to solve problems as well as escape from them. When reading for this session, I came across a quote which refers to drama but which I think perfectly sums up the use of our imagination when given a stimulus of any sort and the main lesson I learned today:

“[Drama] represents an opportunity to construct powerful and imaginary worlds together and enables speculation, modification and transformation of our understandings.” (Grainger, 2003, p.45)

References 

Craft, A. (2007) Creativity and possibility in the Early Years. [Online] Available: www.tactyc.org.uk/pdfs/reflection-craft.pdf [Accessed: 1 October 2017].

Grainger, T. (2003) Creative teachers and the language arts: Possibilities and potential. Education 3-13: The International Journal of Primary, Elementary and Early Years Education. Vol.31(1), pp.43-47.

Lehrer, J. (2012). Imagine: How Creativity Works. [Online] Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ufnp89NOrel&feature=youtu.be [Accessed: 2 October 2017].

Smith, F. (2009) Why Arts Education Is Crucial, and Who’s Doing It Best. [Online] Available: https://www.edutopia.org/arts-music-curriculum-child-development [Accessed: 2 October 2017].

 

Week 2 – Childhood Development in the Arts

Today was our second input for Integrated Arts and we focussed on Childhood Development within the arts. In preparation for today’s lecture I read a chapter of Fleming (2012) ‘The Arts in Education: an introduction to aesthetics, theory and pedagogy’ and we considered this as a group in the lecture. This piece of writing discusses the justification of teaching the arts and has a very insightful and positive outlook on the affects that the arts can have on the development of children. We were all given a printed page from the chapter we had read and were asked to annotate it with visual representations of the meaning behind the text. I was given page 14. I drew an eye to represent the ‘insight into human situations’ which Fleming discusses, and a balanced set of scales to represent the balance which Fleming labels as a very important consideration if we want to make the most of all of the possible benefits from the arts. I feel that the main message conveyed by the text on this page is that different art forms have different impacts; some which are direct and some which are discrete. I love this idea as a way to develop contextual understanding of a piece of text in the classroom as I feel that it would have the power to connect even the most reluctant learners to both literacy and visual art. I also believe that it is a fantastic way of allowing learners to develop that which they may not be able to express with the written word. The development of higher order thinking skills such as analysis and evaluation may come before the learner is able to display them using the written word. Using art in this way can allow for them to make use of and further develop these skills. As lesson 5 from Elliot Eisner’s (2002) 10 Lessons the Arts Teach discusses that we know more than we can say, it is clear that this method can be used to make visible that which we may not be able to put into words. This method could also be used with sheet music, allowing learners to appreciate the impact that the arts in the form of sounds can have on their emotions and to represent this impact using different visual techniques such as colours, lines, materials and textures which they feel to be appropriate. I believe that it will only be an effective method if people are left to do whatever they wish and are reassured that however they choose to represent the text or music, they will never be wrong. This taught me a valuable lesson in itself today as I feel that as a teacher I must reassure the pupils if they are to truly benefit from the arts. This is to say that I must put aside my natural wishes to ‘help’ the pupils in my class by directing their art works towards what I think is right, and focus on helping them to discover their own interpretations by giving them just enough guidance for them to explore their own imaginations, emotions and understandings.

In the workshop after today’s lecture, we analysed collections of visual art works by children in the early level, first level and second level of school. At Early level, children will often use big arm movements and punch the paper with their drawing tool, making scribbles which can be confused by some as having no meaning (McAuliffe, 2007). However, this form of visual art has lots of meaning which can often only be described by the creator. McAuliffe (2007) suggests that questions about these pieces must be asked carefully and with an encouraging tone. This has shown me that as a teacher I must show the learners that I care about these pieces of expression just as much as I care about their work in literacy and mathematics. The teacher of the pupil who created this piece has written on the back of it that the task was to use paint to fill the whole composition. The learner has done this successfully showing their interest in different colours, shapes, lines and textures. The teacher has provided the learner with an A3 sheet of tan coloured paper which gives them enough space to be creative and a black canvas on which most colours, including both black and white, can be seen. The nature of this piece suggests that the learner has experimented with a relatively new material and has shown creativity by using different physical motions to apply the paint to the paper.

Moving into the first level, learners tend to become more aware of their surroundings and become more conscious of pressure and of the learned behaviour of correctness. They are still expressing their emotions and creativity through visual art as they can often be seen to represent that which they know is there rather than what they can see. This displays that they are still to some extent using their imagination when creating pieces of visual art as they are not copying exactly what is in front of them. Both of these pieces show  the attempts of learners to make their drawings and paintings more realistic and life-like through increased detail and perspective. However, as discussed by McAuliffe (2007), at this level they are often left feeling disheartened and unhappy with their work as despite their attempts, they cannot make it look as life-like as they wish to. This is shown by the perspective of the heads facing side-ways in the pencil drawing and by the perspective of the bridge in the painting. This has taught me that as a teacher at this stage of development I must focus on maintaining the imagination wherever possible and supporting the fact that representing exactly what we see is not always the best way to represent our own interpretation of it.

Finally, looking at the work of second level students showed me that their work is often commended only if it displays a high level of detail and a ‘realistic’ perspective. However, many of the pieces of work are copies of that of famous artists and this displays that young people at this age are beginning to feel self-conscious about their work and to lack confidence due to fear of doing it wrong. As a child in school myself I remember feeling that as I moved into secondary education, my imagination was unimportant compared to my academic abilities and my abilities to demonstrate any so called talents which I had. The imagination of young people should instead be celebrated and maintained for as long as possible and the best way to do this is to make use of it to show its value. In order for this to happen I should provide learners with opportunities to experiment with a wide range of media and provide them with a wide range of skills and allow them to interpret artistic tasks however best they see fit; encouraging a balance between creation and observation (Fleming, 2012).

Overall, today I learned various methods and ways to support the development of children through the arts in order to maintain the imagination and to channel different means of understanding and learning. I shall continue to look into this further as I believe that it is a topic which holds a lot of potential for engaging learners in the classroom and allowing them to develop and make use of higher order thinking skills.

References

Eisner, E. (2002) The Arts and the Creation of Mind. Yale University Press.

Fleming, M. (2012) The arts in Education: an introduction to aesthetics, theory and pedagogy. London: Routledge.

McAuliffe, D. (2007) Foundation and Primary Settings. In: Cox, S. et al. (eds.) Teaching Art and Design 3-11. London: Continuum, pp.26-29.