By Carol McDonald, HM Inspector and Lead Officer for secondary inspection
Time to reflect on inspection evidence is always an interesting and key part of our work. Reviewing our findings for the recent report ‘Quality and improvement in Scottish education 2012 – 2016’ (QuISE) highlighted some important strengths in the secondary sector over a period with significant changes to the curriculum.
Inspectors appreciate the opportunity inspection offers to engage in dialogue with staff, parents, partners of the school and the young people themselves. We learn a great deal from our discussions which informs many aspects of our work.
You can read the secondary chapter from QuISE on our website. In secondary schools, inspectors found the curriculum in most schools evolving as new qualifications replaced old ones. Much of the work in schools focused on implementing new qualifications and increasing the range of accreditation available to young people in the senior phase.
Staff in schools recognised that to continue to improve attainment, improvements to learning pathways from S1 to S3 are required. Young people are well supported by the good relationships they enjoy with their teachers. However, too much variability was observed in the quality of learning and teaching. Schools need to continue to work to ensure staff share a good understanding of the best features of effective practice.
Our evidence shows that schools need to use the wide range of evidence available to ensure that school improvement planning is manageable and achievable. The evidence from Insight, and from teacher’s professional judgements on the progress of young people, needs better used to inform improvement planning.
Schools are working effectively with partners to develop the young workforce using a range of innovative approaches. Senior staff in schools are using the Career Education Standard 3-18 (CES), the Work Placement Standard (WPS) and Guidance on School/Employer Partnerships as a platform to promote and develop DYW in their schools. The use of the standards and the guidance to align and co-ordinate activity is still at an early stage. Teaching staff, young people and employers are not yet aware of the entitlements and the expectations within the standards and guidance.
Our inspections in the current academic year show improvements in arrangements for assessing and tracking the progress of young people across all aspects of their learning. Using this evidence to implement appropriate interventions for individuals is key to improving outcomes for young people. Collating the evidence at a department, faculty and whole school level allows staff to analyse and act upon necessary improvements. Central to this work is the reliability of the assessment evidence. We are seeing teachers beginning to make good use of the benchmarks to support them in this essential work.
In the best examples, schools are identifying, and taking account of, a range of features which may influence outcomes for young people. This includes factors such as being “looked after” (LAC), living in areas of social deprivation (SIMD 1 and 2) and having identified additional support requirements. These factors need taken into account when planning learning for young people.
As staff continue to work hard in the interests of their pupils, they recognise that they are part of a wider team of adults that provide the necessary support to help young people succeed. It is good to see, and hear about, the successes of schools in improving outcomes for the young people in their community.
As we look ahead to next year’s inspections, I look forward to seeing these areas develop further, helping improve attainment for our young people.